I read an article written by Robert T. McGee, Director of Macro Strategy and Research, US Trust, which I found interesting. It appeared in issue 26. 2014 of a US Trust publication entitled Capital Acumen under the title “Income Inequality: U. S. Versus the World. He starts out agreeing that income inequality has increase in the developed world over the last three decades. Included in his article is a chart showing the Per Capita GDP, the GINI (%) coefficient and the ratio of the richest 10% Average income to the Poorest 10%. (The GINI coefficient measures income inequality. 0% is the case where all households earn the same income and 100% if one household has all the income and the all the others have none. So the lower the coefficient the smaller the income inequality) He sites globalization and technology, changes in policies and institutions, and differences in education among the reasons. He points out that “the average person in the rich world would be among the best off with the same income in a poor country”. This fact draws immigrants from poor countries who take low paying jobs, into the US. He concludes that inequality is overwhelmingly caused by inequality between rich and poor countries rather than inequality within countries suggesting that inequality should be judged on an absolute rather than a relative scale. By the absolute measure, poverty is minimal in the rich world. He ends his opening salvo with “Other than the corrosive effects of envy, there is less reason to care if income inequality is high as long as the bottom decile has adequate income”. Following is a list of the top ten economies giving their Per capita income, GINI (%) and the ratio of the Richest 10% average income to the poorest 10%. United States, $ 51.7, 45, 15; China, $9.2, 47.4, 21.8; Japan, $35.9, 37.6, 4.5;Germany, $38.7, 27, 6.9; France, $35.3, 32.7, 8.3; United Kingdom, $36.6, 40, 13.6; Brazil, $11.7, 50.8, 37.1; Russia, $17.5, 41.7, 12.8; Italy, $29.8, 31.9, 11.7; India, $3.8, 36.8, 8.6l WORLD, $12.2, 39, 12. I have some real issues with his logic. Poverty is not an absolute. The idea of being poor goes beyond just do you have a roof over your head and some food in the stomach. By that standard, homeless guys sleeping in Shinjuku under the L in large cardboard boxes and begging for their meals are not poor. They have a roof over their heads and are not starving. Reality is that we humans have needs beyond these two and most of those are relative. The absolute argument is weak. The same logic says that by absolute measures a poor man today is better off than a rich man thousands of years ago. The cardboard box is more comfortable than a cold, damp cave; their life expectancy is much greater; they can see and be more aware of the world around them, read and write, flush their toilets, and of course they can watch TV. That being said, I would bet that a rich man then, as a rich man now, would be smiling more often than a poor man. In fact I saw a compelling argument (I think it was from the right) on TV supporting poverty in relative terms. It talked about the relatively low cost of living, specifically in Texas, where a poor man by national poverty standards could live quite well compared to someone with the same income in New York. The argument went further, justifying low wages, again because the cost of living is low. (I have some sympathy for that position.) I am also not sure about the point of immigrants from poor countries taking low paying jobs significantly contributing to the inequality. Where I live, I see many more Indian immigrants working as doctors, engineers and businessmen than I do bagging groceries in the Piggly Wiggly. I don’t know if this is still the case, but after the large expansion of land was finished, US emigration policy, (unless one was seeking asylum or had other unique circumstance only allow more educated and higher skilled immigrants into the country. I believe the lower skilled labor primarily entered through illegal means. As to the causes of inequality, Robert McGee, said “research at the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) found “trends in technology, policies and education”, were the key drivers of changes in wage inequality and employment in the United States, Germany, Norway and other countries”. “Policies and institutional effects such as declining unionization, product market deregulation, declining tax wedges and reduced unemployment benefit replacement rates were found to raise inequality, but also to increase employment.” He then goes on to says that growth in education not only reduces inequality but increases employment. “Shifting demographics have substantial effects on income inequality. These include increased female participation, smaller household structures (single parents), increased part time work versus full time work and an increased disparity in men’s earnings. Assortative mating, an increased tendency of comparably compensated partners to form households, can add to inequality in a society.” I can’t disagree with that except to give some possible explanations for these factors. Increased female participation was brought about by rising costs and stagnating family income pushing women into the workforce. This exacerbated the situating, with women’s increased participation the labor pool grew further driving down the market price for labor. I don’t believe the smaller household structure is primarily attributed to single parents. As a society advances, the marrying age increases and young people don’t immediately move from their parent’s home into a family, but spend some time living alone. With two members of a household forced to work, there is a willingness, if not a desire, for one member to work part time and part time work pays less and provides fewer benefits. I think that more and more people are living in homogeneous communities thus limiting the opportunity to meet people in different socioeconomic conditions. Mr. McGee goes on to write about income mobility citing a study by Raj Chetty, a professor of economics at Harvard which says that the odds of a young person staying in the bottom decile today are not much different than they were 30 and 50 years ago. I would add that given the larger gap between the bottom and top 10%, when they move up from the bottom, they are not moving into quite as nice a spot. Also I think a more significant measure of mobility would be the odds of moving from the bottom 10% to the top 10%. My guess is that the odds would not be the same today. Ho goes on to say that in northern European countries it is easier to move from the bottom to the top, because of the smaller difference. My comment here is a “well duh”. He goes on to say the it is more appropriate to compare the United States, which has the largest income inequality of the 10 largest economies, to world inequality rather than the other large economies because we have the greatest diversity in our population, an unusually large share of the world’s richest most educated and entrepreneurial people. I’m not sure what he is saying here except maybe that “them that’s got, git”. The author concludes that “America’s income inequality is the natural outcome of being the land of opportunity” and ends with the right wing mantra: “The real issue is raising living standards and making opportunity for advancement as accessible as possible, It’s important that envy and resentment of success not stymie the effort to grow the economy, because the evidence is overwhelming that regardless of inequality trends, it takes a rising tide to lift all boats.” While the tide has risen and the yachts are at ever greater heights, I think it would be hard to convince the bottom decile that they are any better off in their dinghies.
Tuesday, June 24, 2014
Wednesday, April 16, 2014
"Showing Off"
I saw a presentation on TED Talks not too long ago that spoke about the human ability to adapt. The presenter suggested that there is a basic level of happiness, driven by brain chemistry, genetics and some other factors, though they may slowly change over time, determine part of the person’s character. If they encounter an event however pleasant or tragic, within a year they return to their inherent level of happiness, whether high or low. In a different talk I saw a cheerful paraplegic who participated in the development of a system that allowed him to control robotic devices with his eyes. He got a kick out of demonstrating this by flying a drone on stage from a remote location, Other dramatic examples of our adaptability I’ve run across come to mind. Years ago I saw a photograph of an old woman in a magazine, a push cart peddler during the German occupation in a Russian city. Her cart was set up beneath a tree from which a man was hanging by his neck. My first reaction was: “how could she be so callous?” But upon reflection, men hanging from trees, over time became the norm and she adapted. I remember the gasoline shortage in the seventies when we had to line up for gas. Before the shortage we would not even tolerate two cars in front of us but after only a couple of weeks, I would consider it a lucky day if I only had to wait one hour. I remember certain rules in place when I was stationed in Saigon in the mid-sixties. One of them was “don’t stand in groups on the sidewalk waiting for a bus, stay in a building till it comes”. From time to time there were incidents in the city where a hotel housing soldiers or a restaurant would get bombed and for a day everyone followed this rule. However, by the next day things were back to normal, everyone congregating on the sidewalk in bunches waiting for a bus or a taxi. The speaker also touched on the fleeting nature of joy derived from the acquisition of material goods. This happiness, he claimed, is short lived, lasting only a few days, weeks or months. I think the way we extend or repeat the pleasure is by “showing off”. We become accustomed to our trinkets no matter how grand or small. The vacation homes, the fast cars, a piece of art, a yacht or a nice piece of clothing are soon taken for granted and the happiness they once brought becomes a distant memory. By sharing these and the stories related to them we revive, at least momentarily, the pleasures they once offered us. The same can be said of even the more esoteric things that bring some happiness into our lives. Guiding someone on a sightseeing tour of a place that we were once fascinated by but now don’t even notice can bring its beauty back into our eyes or the marvel into our hearts. So don’t judge us showoffs so harshly. We are probably just trying to re-live past joys and not demonstrating our superiority.
Posted by PoliticAli at 6:20 PM 0 comments
Monday, March 24, 2014
Back to the Dark Ages
Following Is extracted from Merriam-Webster’s on line Dictionary.
civilized
adjective
: marked by well-organized laws and rules about how people behave with each other
: polite, reasonable, and respectful
: pleasant and comfortable
Full Definition of CIVILIZED
: characteristic of a state of civilization
Posted by PoliticAli at 7:16 PM 3 comments
Wednesday, December 4, 2013
Walking in Someone Else's Shoes
There is an old Native American (I think) proverb that says “don’t judge someone until you have walked a mile in their shoes”. Our human nature, however, is to judge, in particular the poor if we are not one of them. Far from imagining what it would be like in their shoes, we tend to look at their circumstances from our own point of view and assigning our own sets of priorities. We see people making decisions that to us seem incomprehensible and too often attribute them to character flaws; old ladies using their social Security money on slot machines; victims of Katrina wasting the couple hundred or maybe thousand dollars they received on the riverboat casinos; people who barely have enough to eat, smoking; barns and farmhouses in shambles; garbage strewn in the streets; the list goes on. We think “how can they? I would never live like that. I wouldn’t gamble what little money I have away and give up smoking and fix my barn and not allow garbage to accumulate in the street. There has to be something wrong with these people”. We think about what we would like to do in a given situation, but in reality, in that circumstance, most likely we would do something totally different. Given our genes, culture, experience and in particular, circumstance, we put thing in a particular order of importance. Our judgment of others assumes they have the same set of priorities, are in our settings and benefit from our experiences. The fact of the matter is that not only do they not, but our own priorities, settings and experiences are constantly changing. A child is born, we lose a job, win a lottery, become ill, we grow wiser or become more cynical. In reality as we go through life and as our surroundings and experiences change, so do our priorities. Things once thought to be of utmost importance can become trivial. Unfortunately we can never walk in someone else’s shoes. We cannot have an identical makeup or experience and even if we did, we cannot occupy the same space in time. The best we can do is try to imagine what might be important to someone given their set of circumstances. But even that is a poor approximation of a stroll in their shoes. The other day I read a piece in the Huffington Post by Linda Tirado who in the most eloquent way, tries to explain the thought process of a very poor person. From the article I think one can get a peek into their priorities and decisions, which from our perspective may have seemed lousy, but now start to be a little more understandable. Below is a link to that article. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/linda-tirado/why-poor-peoples-bad-decisions-make-perfect-sense_b_4326233.html
Posted by PoliticAli at 3:38 PM 0 comments
Wednesday, October 9, 2013
Leadership
There are a few characteristics of a good leader. Among them are; courage, judgment and experience. To explain this I often used the “scraping of window panes” metaphor. Here the leader is on the inside of a room and there is something going on outside that they need to act on quickly. In front of them is a window with a number of panes all painted opaque. Were they clear, the scene would be apparent and the action obvious. A good leader starts by scraping a bit of the paint off of one pane and gets a glimpse of the scene. That small segment suggests they may want to scrape another bit of a pane at the far end. There is starting to appear a hint of an image. They scrape a bit of another pane, go back to the first and scrape a little more and then, though without a full picture, they see enough to make a decision. In the example above the leader exhibited a characteristic essential to good leadership. First and foremost they were willing to take a risk and make a decision without waiting for all the pieces of the puzzle to be in place. I have seen very capable people continue scraping each pane clear and see the entire scene before taking action. They are afraid of being wrong, whereas the leader above was willing to chance and make the decision. At this point I might add that for different actions there are different degrees of probability that are prudent. A surgeon need a very high probability and would be justified to scrape much of the window clear but most of us are in positions where we can afford to be wrong and often inaction is more consequential than wrong action. Another attribute required to make a decision with minimal scraping is experience. With experience one has seen many scenes outside the window and seeing only a few key pieces can imagine the full picture. People without the experience, though brave, need to clear a larger portion of the window to see the same amount of the scene to make a decision. The third attribute is judgment. As they scrape small segments of a pane and catch a glimpse of the scene, they need to decide where might there be another segment that will most probably lead them quickly to the whole picture. Someone, courageous and experienced but without good judgment, unable to figuring out where the most probable bit of a scene lies that will help form enough of a picture will need to scrape a large portion of many panes. Without the courage, judgment and experience, no matter how bright the individual, they will spend too much time gathering information or if not, see the wrong picture and though in positions of leadership, will not be followed.
Posted by PoliticAli at 1:17 PM 0 comments
Tuesday, June 18, 2013
The "Real" America
Sarah Palin spoke of the “real America”. The Governor while running for vice president, when visiting a rural area said it was good to be in the real America. I believe in all sincerity she sees the real America as the sum of the white and Christian rural parts of the country. A couple of weeks ago I went to the Registry of Motor Vehicles in an industrial urban city and there I saw, what I think is another real America. There were about one hundred people there of many ethnicities, races and socio-economic groups. There were Puerto Ricans and Latinos from Central and South American and Brazilians, some speaking fluent English others Spanish and Portuguese. There were African Americans and more recent arrivals from Africa. There were people of different European ancestries and people from the Middle East and Asia. There were laborers, students and businessmen in suits. Siting there waiting for my turn, Sarah Palin came to mind and I thought that had she been in this room, she would not have acknowledged this as America. I think one of our fundamental divides is between the urban and the rural. Each with different political interests and cultures and I think, like Sarah Palin, we don’t understand or recognize each other. I live in the suburbs, an area that doesn’t quite fit either the urban or rural, pretty much am isolated from both Sarah Palin’s and the America I saw at the Registry. I was fortunate to have had opportunities to live, though most of it in the suburbs, in my early years in very rural areas and my teenage years in a city. I first became conscious of this divide when I took a train from San Jose to San Francisco fifteen years ago, sharing it with a large variety of people. Based on that refreshing experience, more recently, when I had to go on business to San Francisco, I decided to fly into Oakland and instead of hiring a car, I took a bus to the train station and then a train across the Bay. Though brief, the exposure to the variety of races, ethnicities and cultures was enlightening. I propose that we all take an opportunity to spend time in an environment with people we are not accustomed to being around. Furthermore, when evaluating a politician running for an office where they will represent a diverse group, we should look at their record of time spent with the range of their future constituencies. Whatever you may think about our current president Barak Obama, he would have an impressive record on this dimension having been brought up by grandparents in the rural Midwest, spending time in Hawaii and Indonesia and working in the inner Chicago city. I find it interesting that people on the extreme right make fun of his work as a “community organizer” in the inner city. Better he should have been insulated in the real (business) world. Spending time with different people allows us to recognize their humanity on a more visceral level and become empathetic with their wants and fears. Not having had the firsthand experience, we tend to use our imaginations, with liberals exaggerating the plight and conservatives the lack of dignity. At the start of the first war with Iraq, I went to India on business for a few days. As I was accustomed, I went for an early morning walk and came across a group of squatters (I think they were “Untouchables”) living in shacks on the grounds of what appeared to be a government building of some sort. As I walked past, I saw two young people (I don’t recall if they were two men or a man and woman) squatting on the sidewalk, brushing their teeth and spitting the rinsing water into the gutter. My first reaction was to feel sorry for them, seeing the conditions they lived in. But as I approached them, they were talking and laughing with such gusto that I became jealous of them. I couldn’t remember the last time I laughed so heartily.
Posted by PoliticAli at 11:53 AM 0 comments
Friday, March 22, 2013
A Military Without War
Recently the Senate passed an amendment that reduced funds for the National Science Foundation completely eliminating funding for any political science projects with two exceptions. They would continue funding these if they were shown to advances the military or our economy. This prompted me to get back to a subject I have often pondered and discussed. Is there a benefit to a military, other than fighting a war and how can we exploit it? George Orwell wrote a novel about ongoing battles against an imaginary enemy somewhere “over there”. The ruling government used the threat of an invasion to more easily control its population. More recently, Paul Krugman, Nobel Laureate writing for the New York Times, in an interview talked about the economic boom brought about by the Second World War. With tongue in cheek, he suggested we should proclaim an impending invasion from outer space and preparing for it would get us out of these economic doldrums. I think he was only half kidding. So how could we benefit from a military with no war? Conservatives have been reluctant to support government funded development but have shown a willingness to spend large sums of money on defense. With the ever increasing rate of technological innovation and global competition, it is imperative that we stay ahead of the curve. Basic research is not something suitable for private enterprises and in recent years, large companies such as IBM, known for their applied research and development in the past have been shrinking their scientific staff and facilities and looking outside, not only IBM, but outside the US. In the past science and development for the military was also of interest to the private sector. Some examples are: Development in material science of carbon nano-fibers has the promise of stronger and more lightweight armament for the military and lightweight vehicles with lower fuel consumption for the private sector. The military uses lasers for target designation and shooting down enemy missiles and in the private arena lasers are used in hundreds of applications from bar-code scanners and surgery to toys. Space science has always been closely affiliated with the military but has brought about civilian benefits like GPS and weather satellites. Of course there is the internet. As demonstrated by the amendment the Senate just passed, the Republicans, ever suspicious of science, are reluctant to spend on any development that is not of interest to our military particularly that whose aim is of benefit primarily for our poorest citizens who in many of their minds are only “takers”. Since almost anything can be argued to be of significance to the military, with Republican support we should increase the military budget and move more science into defense. A defense department in a non-war setting could be the hub of research and development and as the research is defense related we could more easily keep it within our borders giving an advantage to our industries Another thought, though much more farfetched, is to implement universal service as is the case in Israel and use the soldiers, sailors, marines and airmen to work on projects not well suited to the private sector but would be of benefit to our society as a whole. This could serve a number of purposes. The draft could be arranged so that once someone, man or woman, reaches a certain age, if they are not in school, they would need to serve in the military for two or three years. Attending school would not release them from the obligation but only postpone it. The potential benefits, as I see them, are many. The number of idle young would be greatly reduced. Part of the service would include education and training constantly adjusted to the needs of industry as these change. The discipline which unfortunately is too lacking in too many of our homes can be taught and thus better prepare the young for the workplace they will enter upon completion of their service. One of the problems we face that will only increase with the growing income gap is that people are becoming more and more separated and with this separation more suspicious of each other. I found that when I was a new recruit in the army, with everyone wearing the same clothing and haircuts a lot of what we use to prejudge people based on our ignorance or prejudice is greatly reduced. Individuals from different races, religions and classes can come to better know each other and become more empathetic to a wider range of humanity. (This smells a bit of social engineering and I would keep this benefit under wraps.) A lot of our cities are falling apart. This force could be used to clean up vacant lots and demolish abandoned buildings. They could beautify our parks and other recreation areas. Instead of low cost “guest” workers, farm labor could be provided by these soldiers. In fact as part of the preparation for the outside world, I would have rural kids working on inner city projects and city kids on rural ones. The older and better educated individuals could spend time working in facilities providing assistance, including medical, to the poor. There is a strong desire on the part of conservatives to secure our border. A portion of the soldiers could be deployed there. The recent decade has seen an increase in catastrophic climatic events which are expected to not only continue but to increase. The military could be used to build levies and other barriers against the rising sea levels and be deployed to areas that have been hit by tornados, hurricanes, blizzards and tsunamis. Of course a segment of the military population would continue to prepare for battle, whatever form that may take in the future. Our potential enemies would be overwhelmed by the size of our military and may be reluctant to confront us and in the event of an unavoidable conflict, we could easily and quickly shift to a wartime footing. (This could be a selling point for the right.) And finally, with this much of the labor force taken out of the labor market, wages would increase and after completing the service, young people would return to a better place in better shape to contribute to keeping it that way. Also, since the low wage work would be done by the military, there would be less to attract unskilled immigrants. I don’t believe there is a snowball’s chance in hell that any of this could, or for that matter maybe should, be implemented. But such thinking out of the box could encourage others to also do so and contribute to the development of policies to help us succeed in the volatile future.
Posted by PoliticAli at 7:58 PM 0 comments
